The biggest sin? It isn't very funny. The slapstick is tired, the animal CGI hasn’t aged well (the lip-sync on Garfield is distractingly stiff), and the “British” humor boils down to stuffy butlers and golf jokes. Even the climactic chase sequence involving a dozen angry animals feels more like a theme park filler ride than a proper finale.
Garfield: A Tail of Two Kitties (2006) proves that a fat cat can indeed get lazier—not just in his fictional world, but in the screenwriting department as well. While the original 2004 film was a harmless, if forgettable, slice of nostalgia, this UK-set sequel feels like a direct-to-DVD script that accidentally got a theatrical budget. garfield 2
A Lasagna-Sized Letdown: More Filler Than Thriller The biggest sin